He is on the books of SS Virtus and wears shirt number 25. His main role on the pitch is Forward. His estimated market valuation currently stands at 100K €.

His latest transfer saw him join SS Virtus from ASD Savignanese via on 2022-07-11.

During the San Marino Campionato di Calcio 2025-2026 campaign, Simone Benincasa made 20 appearances, scoring 3 goals and adding 0 assists. He averaged 0.2 goals per match from 0 shots, with 0 on target.